Do we need specialisation in Yoga therapy?
- Yogacharya Dr.Ananda Balayogi Bhavanani
- 1 day ago
- 3 min read
Updated: 48 minutes ago
Dr. Ananda Balayogi Bhavanani has consistently argued that specialization in Yoga Therapy is valuable only when it serves, rather than replaces, the holistic vision of Yoga. His central criticism is not of specialization itself, but of reductionism—the tendency to reduce yoga to a collection of techniques for treating diseases.
He often distinguishes between Yoga Chikitsa (authentic yoga therapy) and what he calls "Yogopathy."
According to him, Yogopathy is the practice of asking questions such as:
"Which asana for diabetes?"
"Which pranayama for hypertension?"
"Which meditation for anxiety?"
This disease-centered approach mirrors conventional symptom-based medicine rather than the philosophy of Yoga. (PubMed Central (PMC))
The whole person comes before the disease
Dr. Ananda frequently states that the yoga therapist should treat the person, not the pathology.
Instead of beginning with a diagnosis such as hypertension or arthritis, the therapist asks:
Who is this person?
What is their lifestyle?
What are their relationships?
What are their fears and aspirations?
What is the state of their body, breath, mind, emotions and spirit?
What are the root causes of their imbalance?
The disease is seen as only one expression of a much deeper imbalance affecting multiple dimensions of life. This reflects the yogic understanding of the Pancha Kosha, where disturbance may begin in the mental, energetic or emotional layers long before appearing in the physical body. (UBC Press)
Specialization is acceptable—but should never become compartmentalization
As Director of an Institute of Yoga Therapy and a medical doctor himself, Dr. Ananda certainly recognizes the need for expertise in areas such as:
Oncology
Neurology
Cardiology
Mental health
Women's health
Sports medicine
However, he would argue that these are areas of application, not separate philosophies of yoga.
For example:
A therapist specializing in cancer care should still understand:
nutrition
breathing
stress responses
family dynamics
meaning and purpose
spirituality
quality of life
rather than merely teaching a protocol for chemotherapy side-effects.
Similarly, a neurological yoga therapist is not simply prescribing balance exercises but helping restore integration throughout the person's entire life.
Salutogenesis rather than pathology
One of Dr. Ananda's strongest influences is Salutogenesis—the science of the origins of health.
Instead of asking:
"How do we fight disease?"
he encourages therapists to ask:
"How do we cultivate health?"
This shifts the focus from illness management toward developing:
resilience
adaptability
self-awareness
self-regulation
inner harmony
meaning in life
Health is viewed as a dynamic continuum rather than merely the absence of disease. (Yogavani)
The therapist matters as much as the technique
Another hallmark of his philosophy is that the therapist's own embodiment of Yoga is more important than technical specialization.
He repeatedly emphasizes that:
authenticity heals,
relationship heals,
presence heals,
compassion heals.
He even recounts that some patients improved not because of a particular posture but because they felt genuinely seen, respected and safe. In his words, "the therapist is inseparable from the therapy." (Sannidhi Yoga)
Against protocol-driven yoga
Dr. Ananda is cautious about the increasing tendency to create standardized yoga protocols for every disease.
Protocols are useful:
for research,
for teaching,
for ensuring safety.
But he believes they should never replace individualized assessment.
Every session should be adapted according to:
age
constitution
abilities
psychosocial situation
motivation
stage of illness
spiritual orientation
readiness for change
rather than simply following a disease-specific sequence. (Sannidhi Yoga)
His philosophy could be summarized as follows:
Reductionist specialization | Dr. Ananda's holistic specialization |
Disease-centred | Person-centred |
Symptom management | Root-cause understanding |
Protocol-driven | Individualized |
Technique-focused | Relationship-focused |
Physical body | Body, breath, mind, emotions, behaviour and spirit |
Cure | Healing and growth |
"What practice for this disease?" | "Who is this person, and what will help them evolve?" |
A statement that captures his philosophy
Perhaps the most representative expression of Dr. Ananda's viewpoint is:
"Taking the yoga out of yoga therapy leaves you with just therapy." (Yogavani)
In other words, he does not oppose specialization in yoga therapy. Rather, he believes that specialization should arise from a deep understanding of Yoga as a complete way of life, where disease-specific expertise is integrated into a broader framework of healing the whole person—physically, mentally, emotionally, socially, and spiritually.
This is why he consistently advocates Yoga Chikitsa over Yogopathy, emphasizing that true yoga therapy is fundamentally about restoring wholeness rather than merely treating illness.
Comments